Guess you guys are correct, it does look more like No. 1 patented the more you look at it. As I had never seen it before I almost passed it up. At the auction about 10 items were on a table and the auctioneer called for "choice". Some one got choice for $25.00 and it went on (I didn't bid as I thought it was broken). When choice got down to $5.00 I still wasn't involved, but after it was still on the table I took second choice for $5.00. Now I'm glad I did, but still thought it was broken until I saw the patent picture.